Social Media Sidebar

Announcement

Please sign up, comment on articles and bring your friends!

Current poll

PlanetTech is asking:

What do you think about our new web site?

Love it, indeed
Really good solution
Same as old one
The old one was better
This is a new option

Quote of the day

'By far the greatest danger of Artificial Intelligence is that people conclude too early that they understand it'

 

Eliezer Yudkowsky

40 Years Of U.S. Nutrition Data Is Fatally Flawed

RATE THIS! +54
Posted in Science on 12th Oct, 2013 09:23 AM by AlexMuller

A new study from researchers at the University of South Carolina took a closer look at the numbers from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, or NHANES. NHANES surveys Americans to find out what they've been eating, if they've been sick, that kind of thing.

 

It's used mostly to learn about diseases and health risk factors throughout the country--and this new study says it's wrong. And has been wrong since it began. In 1971.

 
The study was led by epidemiologist Edward Archer, a researcher with a penchant for controversial surveys--he was previously best known for this examination of calories burned by housewives. The latest survey could have an even broader impact: NHANES is a 40-year-old survey, and Archer and his team says it is "physiologically implausible" for the numbers to be correct. The paper concludes that "the ability to estimate population trends in caloric intake and generate empirically supported public policy relevant to diet-health relationships from U.S. nutritional surveillance is extremely limited."
 
NHANES is a combination of a physical checkup with a survey of what each surveyed American ate in the 24 hours preceding the survey. But that list of food eaten is entirely self-administered; there's nobody following people around to make sure they're telling the truth. And it seems like people weren't.
 
This new study says that the majority of the data can't possibly be accurate. Basically, people claimed they ate far less food than their physical checkup indicates they'd need. If an obese person with a very high body mass percentage--body mass and weight being empirical data which the subject can't lie about--reports that he or she consumes 1,500 calories a day, the study gives that person a high "disparity value," a new point of data that the NHANES had not calculated. An obese person may be able to survive on 1,500 calories a day, but that person won't be obese for long, which makes that calorie count unlikely to be true. En masse, if a huge number of people in a certain category (like, say, the obese) have a high disparity number, it's likely that something's wrong here.
 
The worst offenders were the obese, who underreported their calorie intake by 25 and 41 percent in men and women, respectively. A possible culprit is "social desirability bias," in which a survey subject lies in order to provide answers that he or she feels are more acceptable.  
 
The introduction to the paper refers to the methodology of the survey as "indirect" and "pseudo-quantitative." 


Read original article » Back to category

Comments

Author: Guest
Posted: 2013-10-12
+4
Oh skybeast what a sad mixed up person you are. Confirming or challenging studies and data is excellent science, especially if those studies are being relied upon for policy decisions. Reply
Author: Guest
Posted: 2013-10-14
+0
Whats really funny is this body index crap. It tells you nothing about the individual. There would be a lot of angry cave men running around thinking they were fat. Reply
Author: Guest
Posted: 2013-10-23
+0
P7ZCaw Im thankful for the blog post. Want more. Reply
Author: Guest
Posted: 2013-10-26
+0
KPg6wn I cannot thank you enough for the post.Really thank you! Really Cool. Reply
Author: Guest
Posted: 2013-11-01
+0
yd9re9 Very informative blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great. Reply


 

Recent headlines

  • Posted in Hardware on 2017-03-29 09:24:33
    ExoMars: Mars Rover scientists to study Mawrth Vallis.....read more
    Posted in Software on 2017-03-29 09:20:25
    AI to dominate banking, says report..read more
    Posted in Business on 2017-03-29 09:15:30
    Trump signs order undoing Obama climate change policies..read more
    Posted in Hardware on 2017-03-29 09:08:41
    SpaceX launch of private citizens on a lunar orbiting.....read more
    Posted in Business on 2017-03-28 14:55:07
    Bots shift towards AI and garner $24 billion of investment..read more
Posted in Business on 2013-10-10 01:33
China is working towards a manned lunar mission in about.....read more
Posted in Business on 2013-10-20 07:17
Spacex says China is their main competitor for commercial.....read more
Posted in Software on 2013-10-20 06:43
Pirate Bay Browser Clocks 1,000,000 Downloads..read more
Posted in Medicine on 2013-10-10 02:10
Google reportedly investing hundreds of millions into new.....read more
Posted in Medicine on 2013-10-14 03:13
Endothelial Cells Can Repair and Regenerate Organs,.....read more
Posted in Science on 01.01.2010
Spacex says China is their main competitor for commercial.....read more
Posted in Science on 01.01.2010
Staring at Your Phone Could Be Making You Short Sighted..read more
Posted in Science on 01.01.2010
Oculus Rift virtual reality headset coming to mobile, but.....read more
Posted in Science on 01.01.2010
China is working towards a manned lunar mission in about.....read more
Posted in Science on 01.01.2010
Delivering drugs via nanoparticles to target mitochondria..read more

Recent Blog Posts

  • Posted by AlexMuller
    Intensive medical treatment can reverse type 2 diabetes..read more
    Posted by AlexMuller
    Daily consumption of tea protects the elderly from cognitive.....read more
    Posted by AlexMuller
    New analysis method of metabolites accurately predicts whether.....read more
    Posted by AlexMuller
    Unproven stem cell 'therapy' blinds three patients at Florida.....read more
    Posted by AlexMuller
    Indigenous South American group has healthiest arteries of all.....read more

Login to your Account

Login to your PlanetTech Account here

Username:
Password:
Remember me
or

Create a New Account

You just need username and password

The following errors occured:
Username:
Email:
Password:
Verify password:
Remember me